Lonelygirl15 fake? So what?
I originally found Lonelygirl15 in July when I was looking for a popular video on Youtube to explain how silly it is to be impressed by a few hundred thousand views of "Nobody's Watching." Since then I've become a fan of Lonelygirl15, and I honestly believed in her and Daniel. Well, we all know by now that it was fake. But really, whether it's fake or not is not nearly as important as whether it's good or not, and frankly it got less and less interesting right around the time that it was revealed as a fake. Bree is going to be involved in some sort of ritual that her religious cult performs every few years, and her dad is making her take diet pills. She's started sneaking out of the house, which is a good idea, but give me "Proving Science Wrong" or Daniel's crush on Bree any day. Injecting drama and a serialized cult sacrifice plotline isn't helping the show at all. The everyday problems of a young girl are interesting enough.
But what's really annoying me is that the creators are claiming to be inventing a new art form. And it's that claim that I have to call bullshit on. Fiction that claims to be documentary is nothing new. In films it goes back at least to the 1960s with the fictional personal documentary David Holzman's Diary practically pre-dating the real personal documentary. And if they're talking about fake video blogs in particular, I'm going to have to stake a claim to creating one before Loneygirl came on the scene. Granted, hardly anyone watched (23,000 total views on YouTube vs millions for Lonelygirl15) but I started a fake video blog called "Truth @ 15 Frames Per Second" in January. I'm not going to claim I invented anything. I'm sure there were others before me. But I did it before the Lonelygirl15 team, so screw you guys.
Add comment September 14th, 2006
