Who Would Win in a Fight: Logan Echolls vs. Jack Shephard
It’s Thursday. You know what that means? You probably don’t, because I just kind of decided this. Thursday is official Who Would Win in a Fight day for the summer. Think of it as a reward for making it almost all the way through the week.
Seems like last week’s battle between Studio 60 pill-head Matt Albie and bed-hopping brain surgeon Derek Shepherd ended in a decisive victory for our conflicted comedy writer. I support the decision due to Albie’s unhinged nature and comparative bulk.
This week finds a troubled rich kid going head-to-head with yet another doctor named Shephard. It’s Veronica Mars’ on-again-off-again beau Logan Echolls versus Lost’s castaway leader Jack Shephard.

Logan Echolls
Strengths:
- Kind of a sociopath
- Way buff
- Not easily intimidated
Weaknesses:
- Used to pushing around people who are smaller than him (e.g. Piz, that reporter spy from early in season three, organizing bum fights)
- Veronica doesn’t like it when he fights
- Growing rap sheet
Secret Weapon: Baby-face may inspire underestimation
Jack Shephard
Strengths:
- Abrasive stubble could be used as a weapon
- Can take a punch
- Strong-willed, hard to push around
Weaknesses:
- He’s no kid
- When on the island, he’s weary from being exposed to the elements
- When off the island he’s drunk
Secret Weapon: Good at harnessing his rage
4 comments June 21st, 2007