Who Would Win in a Fight: Dr. House vs. Mr. Sheffield
You have spoken. You spake. You’s gone and done it.
You cast your ballots and the Keith Mars/Jack Donaghy match-up goes to Mr. Mars. It wasn’t a squeaker like I thought it was going to be, but it’s probably a bad idea to make predictions on this like this. Who the hell knows what you are thinking, Internet?
Next…
I don’t really know where this match-up came from, but I still find it compelling. It’s Dr. Gregory House versus Maxwell Sheffield (The Nanny).
I guess Cristin suggested British actors who play Americans and for some reason my mind immediately went to Mr. Sheffield. But he actually is a Brit playing a Brit. This makes no sense, but I’m going with it anyway.
So, on one hand we’ve got the crotchety, crutchety Dr. House whose shoots venom out of his eyes. On the other, we’ve got the spry, if kind of foppish, theater-producing Maxwell Sheffield.
We’ll see what happens.

Dr. Gregory House
Strengths:
- Angry by nature/just waiting for an excuse to whoop some ass
- More worldly
- Tougher by a mile
Weaknesses:
- Um, he walks with a limp
- All talk
- We all know that tough talk is protecting a sad, frightened little boy
Secret Weapon: High on pain meds
Maxwell Sheffield
Strengths:
- No stranger to psychological torture at the hands of Nanny Fine
- In shape from all the slapstick comic antics
- In better physical condition
Weaknesses:
- Persnickety
- Lack of resolve/spine (see the Fine/Sheffield will-they-won’t-they romance; the time he said he loved her and then took it back)
- Theater producer
Secret Weapon: Streak of grey in his luxurious mane.
1 comment August 2nd, 2007
It’s time for Pride and Turner Classic Movies is gaying it up all month with 